Question 2 Passes: Massachusetts Public Defenders Win the Right to Form a Union
Staff attorneys at the Committee for Public Counsel Services can now organize. The measure had no organized opposition.
Massachusetts voters approved Question 2, giving public defenders the right to form a union, WBUR reported.
The yes vote means employees of the Committee for Public Counsel Services, the lawyers and advocates who represent people who cannot afford an attorney, can collectively bargain for a contract, which state law had barred, WBUR reported. About 500 lawyers and hundreds of paralegals and support staff work for the agency.
For years they pressed the Legislature for bargaining rights. After making no progress with elected officials, organizers filed the ballot question instead, according to WBUR.
No committee organized against the question. As Boston Uncut reported Nov. 3, Secretary of the Commonwealth William Galvin's office wrote the opposing argument in the state voter guide.
A right, not yet a union
Having the right to form a union is not the same as becoming one, WBUR noted. CPCS employees will have to follow the steps state law requires to win certification.
The 2024 bar advocate standoff
The vote follows a 2024 dispute in which many bar advocates, private lawyers who take cases when public defenders are unavailable, stopped accepting new cases to protest pay of $65 to $85 an hour, the lowest in New England, WBUR reported. Courts were forced to dismiss charges against some defendants because the state could not guarantee their Sixth Amendment right to counsel. The Legislature then raised the hourly rate by $20, less than advocates sought, and ordered CPCS to hire another 300 lawyers.
Additional reporting
Listen Live: Loading...Heart DonateWBURWBUR90.0 WBUR - Boston's NPR News Station Listen Live: Loading...Heart Donate Listen LiveSearchSearchSectionsLocal CoverageArts & CultureBusinessEducationEnvironmentField Guide To BostonHealthInvestigationsCognoscentiBoston News QuizRadioAll Radio ProgramsAll Things ConsideredHere & NowMorning EditionOn PointOn-Air ScheduleWays To ListenPodcastsAll PodcastsBeyond All RepairCircle RoundEndless ThreadLast SeenThe Midnight RebellionViolationEventsCitySpace CalendarWatch Past EventsEvents NewsletterRent CitySpaceThe WBUR FestivalSupportMember ServicesBecome A MemberDonate Your CarJoin The Murrow SocietyMake A DonationBecome A SponsorCreate A Custom PodcastSupport WBUR
About 500 lawyers and hundreds more paralegals and support staff work for the agency. For years, they've pressed the state legislature to let them collectively bargain. Having made no progress with the state's elected officials, organizers decided to put the question to the electorate instead, filing the ballot question.
But having the right to form a union isn't the same as actually becoming a union. The counsel service employees will have to follow the multiple steps the law requires to earn certification. Tuesday night's victory is the latest chapter in the saga of lawyers who work to represent defendants will little financial wherewithal. In 2024, many of the state's bar advocates — private attorneys who pick up the slack when there aren't public defenders available — stopped taking on new cases to protest their own wages. At the time, advocates in Massachusetts were making between $65-85 an hour, the lowest rate in the New England states and a pittance compared to what other private attorneys earn.
The refusal to work worked, sort of. After weeks of saying "no" to new cases, courts were forced to dismiss charges against defendants because the state could not guarantee them their Sixth Amendment right to an attorney. The Legislature finally acted, passing a bill that increased the hourly rate by $20, less than the advocates had asked for. The bill also ordered the CPCS to hire another 300 lawyers.
What is still unknown
The vote margin, which union would seek to represent the lawyers, and when a certification election could happen have not been reported.
The developments described above are drawn from contemporaneous reporting by WBUR. As of Thursday morning, staff attorneys at the Committee for Public Counsel Services can now organize. The measure had no organized opposition. Boston Uncut will update this account if primary agencies release additional records, schedules or statements that change the public facts. Readers seeking the underlying documents should consult the linked sources, which carry the full quotations and agency attributions used here. Where allegations appear, they are labeled as allegations; where vote totals or rankings are cited, they reflect the figures published by the named outlet or agency at the time of reporting.
Coverage of "Question 2 Passes: Massachusetts Public Defenders Win the Right to Form a Union" sits alongside related Massachusetts and national developments this week. The factual spine of this story remains the linked reporting; any interpretation beyond those facts is limited to describing what the record does and does not yet show. Unanswered questions noted above are not speculation — they are gaps in the public record as of the most recent updates reviewed for this article on 2026-11-05.
Public agencies and courts often release follow-up statements days after an initial announcement. This article reflects the record available Thursday. It does not assert motives that officials have not stated, does not invent quotations, and does not treat complaints or charging documents as findings of guilt. Where numbers come from unofficial election returns or preliminary investigative findings, that status is noted in the sourcing.
